Everything Bagel with Scallion Cheese
← Back to Reviews
bagel
B

Everything Bagel with Scallion Cheese

LOCATION

Pio Bagel

6 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217

REVIEWED

December 21, 2025

"As simple as a bagel gets, because I panicked and didn't know how to order"

The first of many bagels, and so also one of the hardest to rate.

The Experience

Not a lot of seating but not a lot of reason to need it. The menu was filled with options, creating a moment of complete panic for a pair of Australians that have never eaten a bagel before.

The best part was the speed; the bagel was handed to us within five minutes of ordering.

The Bagel

We got the "Everything" bagel, which I presume means that it had a lot of seeds or something.

The bagel was nice and chewy (but not too chewy) but it felt like it could have been baked a little more. I don't know, this was my first bagel.

The Cheese

The cheese was GREAT. Turns out I love cream cheese which is a good thing because I've planned to eat a lot of it. The Scallion Cheese was recommended by Caprice, and she picked well.

The serving amount was decent and well applied too.

The Numbers

  • Bagel: $7
  • Wait time: <5 minutes

Overall

This was a good bagel; but I can't give it any higher than a B tier because:

  1. It was a really simple bagel, and I'm guessing that more fillings = more happiness (up to a point)
  2. This was the first bagel ive had, so I really don't know what a "fucking excellent" bagel would taste like.

Would definitely buy one again. This one feels like it's straddling the line right between upper C and lower B tier, but again, I actually don't really know bagels.

The Scores

👅 Taste
6.0/10
🤏 Texture
6.0/10
📸 Presentation
5.0/10
💰 Value
7.0/10
💅 Caprice Factor
7.0/10
Overall
6.5/10

FINAL TIER

B

Good. Worth trying.