B.M.T. Italian Sub
← Back to Reviews
sandwich
D

B.M.T. Italian Sub

LOCATION

Subway

Various Locations

REVIEWED

December 10, 2025

"A baseline comparison. It's Subway – you know what you're getting."

Sometimes you need a control group. Every scientific experiment needs a baseline, and for sandwich reviews, that baseline is Subway.

Why Even Review This?

Look, I'm not here to dunk on Subway. It serves a purpose – it's cheap, fast, and everywhere. But in a city with sandwich options as good as New York's, you deserve better.

The Sandwich

The B.M.T. (Biggest, Meatiest, Tastiest – yes, really) comes with pepperoni, salami, and ham on your choice of bread. I went with Italian herbs & cheese.

The Reality

Everything here is... fine. The bread is soft but lacks any real character. The meats are processed and taste like it. The vegetables are fresh-ish. It's assembled with the enthusiasm of someone who's made 10,000 of these.

To Be Fair

  • It's $7 for a footlong
  • It's consistent – you know exactly what you'll get
  • It's open late
  • They put it in a toaster if you ask

The Point

I include this review not to be mean, but to provide context. When I rate something a 9 or 10, it's in comparison to this – the ubiquitous, adequate, utterly forgettable sandwich experience.

The verdict: If you're at an airport or a highway rest stop? Sure. In Manhattan with countless better options within walking distance? Never.

The Scores

👅 Taste
4.0/10
🤏 Texture
4.5/10
📸 Presentation
3.0/10
💰 Value
6.0/10
💅 Caprice Factor
3.0/10
Overall
4.0/10

FINAL TIER

D

Below average. Skip it.